Rules In My Defense
How to play In My Defense
Age 14+ · 3–8 players · 10 min
The story is ridiculous. Explain yourself.
On this page
The goal
Everyone explains the same ridiculous situation. The Judge picks the most entertaining, convincing or ridiculous explanation, and that player scores a point. There are no right answers and no wrong answers. Only terrible situations and your best defense.
3
Points to win
30
Seconds per defense
1
Judge each round
What you need
- The In My Defense deck
- 3 to 8 players, ages 14 and up
- A timer — a phone works
Who’s who
- The Judge reads the card and picks the winner. They don’t explain that round.
- Everyone else explains themselves.
Setup
- Shuffle the deck and place it face down.
- Choose a player to be the first Judge.
First time playing?
Read the next section out loud once. After one round, everyone will have it.
A round
Each round has one Judge. Everyone else explains themselves.
- Draw a card. The Judge draws the top card and reads it aloud.
- Explain yourself. Starting with the player to the Judge’s left and going around the table, each player has up to 30 seconds to explain why it happened. The best story wins, so make it count.
- Judge chooses. After everyone has explained, the Judge picks their favorite explanation. That player scores 1 point.
- Pass the Judge role. The player to the Judge’s left becomes the new Judge. Start a new round with a new card.
Example card: “You spent $2,000 on a llama. Explain yourself.”
The Judge reads it aloud, the timer starts, and the player on their left gets the first defense. Was it an investment? A rescue mission? A misunderstanding at an auction? It’s up to you.
Winning
The first player to reach 3 points wins the game.
Out of cards?
If the deck runs out, shuffle the discarded cards and keep playing.
Ways to play
Try a variant once everyone knows the basics.
Fast mode
Explanation time drops from 30 seconds to 15.
Debate mode
After each explanation, other players may ask one follow-up question before the Judge decides.
Quick reference
- Judge draws and reads a card.
- Each player defends for up to 30 seconds.
- Judge picks a favorite: +1 point.
- Judge role passes left.
- First to 3 points wins.